It’s a bittersweet 10th anniversary for a gourmet potato-centric restaurant as it closes its last brick-and-mortar restaurant citing multiple factors, including rising operating costs and a decline in consumer spending.
Mr. Potato Spread will shut its doors at 840 Nautica Drive No. 117 in River City Marketplace about 1 1/2 years after opening at the North Jacksonville shopping center near Jacksonville International Airport. Originally scheduled for Tuesday, the closure might happen as early as Monday afternoon depending on its inventory, the restaurant said on social media Monday morning.
The restaurant is known for its jumbo white potatoes and sweet potatoes baked then split down the middle, stuffed with steak, pulled pork, seafood or veggies. The menu also features tater tots, fries, salads and more.
Founders and co-owners Lakita and Aaron Spann ― who launched the spud-focused business from their home kitchen ― announced the closure on social media in a post thanking customers and the community for their love and support over the years.
“We’ve made the tough decision to close this chapter of Mr. Potato Spread. With the rising costs of rent, insurance, and goods, alongside the decline in consumer spending, it has become increasingly difficult to operate comfortably in this space,” they posted on Facebook.
Need a break? Play the USA TODAY Daily Crossword Puzzle.
The Mr. Potato Spread food truck and catering business will remain open and operating as normal, Lakita Spann confirmed to the Times-Union.
Spann posted “we’re still rolling strong with our food truck! You’ll find us popping up at private events, festivals, and all around town.”
“This decision wasn’t easy, but we remain incredibly grateful for the love, support, and community we’ve built over the past decade. Thanks to YOU, we’ve hit so many milestones, and we’re excited to take some time to focus on family and plan for future ventures (more details to come)!” they also posted.
Restaurant sprouts from home kitchen
Mr. Potato Spread began in August 2014 as a catering service, grew into a popular food truck then expanded to the food courts of two Jacksonville area shopping malls and a franchise restaurant.
Initially, the Spanns focused on delivery-only corporate catering. As the popularity of their potatoes grew, they expanded the business in 2016 to include a food truck and added at-home delivery to their catering service.
That, in turn, led them to open successful food court restaurants, first at Regency Square Mall in March 2019 and then at Orange Park Mall in February 2020.
As the Mr. Potato Spread food truck crisscrossed Northeast Florida, it often was in the growing Northside neighborhoods sprouting up around River City Marketplace, UF Health North medical campus and the airport.
As they served up their potatoes, the couple also gathered information from residents and researched data to gauge potential community support and determine the best location for their brick-and-mortar restaurant.
When they scouted out River City Marketplace, the shopping center also was interested in having Mr. Potato Spread, she previously told the Times-Union.
“River City is kind of a big deal for us. … We very much wanted a Northside location. It’s very exciting for us because we’re from the Northside. In our research, we saw the growth that was going on out there and just had one of those moments where it’s ‘oh, heck, let’s just try it and see what happens,’ ” she previously said.
Incredible journey’ ends’:Jacksonville restaurant and sports bar closes after 15 years
Suddenly shutting its doors:Popular Asian restaurant chain abruptly closes North Jacksonville take-out-only location
Rising costs and changing consumer habits take a toll
Mr. Potato Spread survived the COVID-19 Pandemic but the aftermath has proven more difficult and ultimately taken a toll on the business.
The closure of the River City Marketplace restaurant comes three months after Mr. Potato Spread closed in July at the Orange Park Mall Food Court where it had been a mainstay for three years. That decision came as the restaurant’s lease expired at the mall.
“The restaurant industry has experienced significant changes in recent years. By consolidating our operations into one location at River City and our food truck, we can focus on delivering quality over quantity. This strategic move allows us to streamline our efforts and ensure that we maintain the high standards our customers expect,” she said at the time.
The Orange Park closure comes about six months after the first Mr. Potato Spread franchise closed at 7159 Philips Highway a year after its opening.
The restaurant’s original brick-and-mortar location in the Regency Square Mall food court, 9501 Arlington Expressway, closed in September 2022 after about 3 1/2 years.
Customers responded on social media with disappointment but also encouragement as well as suggestions for where the Spanns should bring the food truck.
“I am truly heartbroken I absolutely love, Mr. Potato Spread. We have loved and enjoyed y’all being in our community,” one customer posted.
Another posted “Keep that truck rolling!! You have created a beautiful business!”
Teresa Stepzinski is the dining reporter for the Times-Union. Follow her on X, formerly known as Twitter, @TeresaStepz or reach her via email at [email protected].
If you’re a subscriber, thank you. If not, become a subscriber to get the latest dining coverage.